The Best 5 Sites To Borrow $1000 Dollar Loans
Having terrible credit puts you in a difficult situation, especially when you need money for an emergency. Borrowing from traditional banks is impossible since you will fail credit checks. Fortunately, you have the option of applying for!-->…
Here’s how the financial system has evolved in the ten years after the financial crisis
On the verge of collapse a decade ago, America's financial system was salvaged by an incredible rescue that resurrected Wall Street and the economy but did little to help citizens who felt misled and left to suffer as a result of title!-->…
Overambitious reuse targets need not be the enemy of beverage packaging recycling – EURACTIV.com
Beverage sectors fear that the European Commission's new proposal on packaging legislation is misguided by focusing their sectors almost exclusively on reusable packaging at the expense of recycling systems, rather than…
FIFA chief accuses Qatar’s Western critics of ‘hypocrisy’
Fifa President Gianni Infantino has blasted critics of Qatar's World Cup, accusing European countries of hypocrisy and saying they were unable to teach moral lessons.In a combative 90-minute press conference on the eve of the World…
G20, APEC, ASEAN: world leaders conclude three summits in Asia, Russia firmly on the sidelines
Bangkok, Thailand
CNN
—
The big three world leaders summits that took place across Asia last week made one thing clear: Vladimir Putin is now sidelined on…
European Commission approves zanubrutinib for CLL
The European Commission has approved zanubrutinib for the treatment of adult patients with treatment-naïve or relapsed/refractory chronic lymphocytic leukemia.The European Commission has approved zanubrutinib (Brukinsa) for the treatment of…
The 2°C target is within reach but more ambitious commitments are needed for 1.5°C
New medium-term goals and long-term net-zero commitments, ambitious policy initiatives and technological development are helping to limit future global warming to around 1.8°C.This is a considerable improvement on the previous projection of…
Schengen states extend border checks, ignoring EU court – DW – 11/17/2022
According to the Schengen Agreement, people and goods can freely cross the borders of the 26 signatory countries without any checks or requirements. Internal border controls within the Schengen area can only be reintroduced as a last…
Midterms ‘will not affect US attitude toward protocol’
The outcome of the United States midterm elections will not affect the United States' attitude to the Northern Ireland Protocol, the Foreign Secretary said today.
Speaking to RTÉ in Washington, Simon Coveney said there was bipartisan…
on | The Russian-Ukrainian war will remind world leaders at the G20 summit in Bali of…
As G20 world leaders meet in Bali this week, the economic and geopolitical consequences of the Russia-Ukraine war will weigh heavily on the summit.
After centuries of war, Europeans settled into what they believed to be an…
Launch of an African Union-European Union-United Nations partnership project in support of African…
Download logoUN Assistant Secretary-General for Human Rights Ilze Brands Kehris concluded a visit to Addis Ababa where she co-chaired the official launch of the African Union Compliance and Accountability Framework (AUCF) project ). She…
At a Glance: Sanctions for Cartel Activities in the European Union
PunishmentsPenals sanctionsWhat criminal penalties, if any, are provided for cartel activities?There are no criminal sanctions for cartel activities at EU level. However, criminal sanctions may be imposed at national level in some Member…
EU pressures Iranian leaders with more sanctions
EU ministers tighten sanctions against IranMacron: repression makes it more difficult to relaunch the nuclear agreementStudents demonstrate in favor of a bloggerDUBAI, Nov 14 (Reuters) - Iran's religious leaders faced growing international…
Elon Musk goes to court to pay Tesla who made him the richest person in the world
washington d.c.
CNN
—
Tesla and CEO Elon Musk will go to court this week to defend the huge compensation package that helped make him the richest man in…
US-China rivalry risks blowing up global economy, IMF chief warns
Comment this storyCommentPHNOM PENH, Cambodia — The global economy is splitting into rival blocs, threatening a Cold War revival that would make nearly everyone worse off, the head of the International Monetary Fund said on…
European Commission invites feedback on Market Definition Notice
While the basic principles of the Opinion "stay healthy", the Commission proposed several important revisions to the opinion of "adapt it to the evolution of the practice of the Commission, to the case law of the courts of the EU as well…
Special Mention for Italian Law Enforcement Experts at Eurojust in European Awards for Investigative…
The coordination pool of Italian law enforcement experts seconded to Eurojust received a special mention at the European Investigative and Forensic Journalism Awards ceremony, held in Naples on 11 November. The special mention is…
EU passes law to eliminate CO2 with forests and other carbon sinks
BRUSSELS, Nov 11 (Reuters) - The European Union has passed a law to expand its forests, marshes and other "sinks" that absorb carbon dioxide (CO2), a move that could help the bloc raise its reduction target net greenhouse gas emissions.On…
‘Not the Brexit I wanted’: next boss calls for more foreign workers in UK | Supply…
Simon Wolfson, the chief executive of clothing and homewares retailer Next, urged the government to make it easier for foreign workers to enter the UK and said it was "not the Brexit I wanted".The Tory peer and Brexit supporter said the…
New Belgian legislation on medical devices and in vitro diagnostics comes into force – Osborne…
The transposition of EU medtech regulations is progressing in Belgium – with repercussions for all medtech companies active there.Two new decrees on medical devices were published in the Belgian Official Gazette of October 25, 2022. While…
Brexit is not responsible for our current problems; it’s still an opportunity | Larry Elliot
The British economy is clearly in trouble. Growth has stalled, interest rates are rising and the Treasury is softening the public for another dose of austerity measures.For some, the explanation for these horrors is simple: Britain is…
The EU is incomprehensible – POLITICO
Press play to listen to this article
The European Commission's reputation for using gibberish is second to none – and now the data confirms that perception.
The verdict is in from an analysis of…
Rishi Sunak brings back Bill of Rights to resolve migrant dispute with European Court
Rishi Sunak will bring back Britain's Bill of Rights as part of his bid to stop migrants crossing the English Channel, The Telegraph can reveal.
Ministers are set to introduce legislation to ensure the supremacy of UK courts over…
In trying to quit Russian energy, the EU traded one dictator for another
For years, the European Union (EU) has relied on Russia to provide the oil and gas it needs to power industries and heat homes. Last year, 40% of the gas flared by the Europeans came from Russia, and the bloc paid $108 billion to the…
GAO on Executive Confidentiality. Phished Dropbox. NLRB on workplace surveillance. The collection…
In one look.GAO calls for dedicated privacy leadership within the executive branch.The Dropbox data breach stems from a phishing scam.The NLRB's top lawyer focuses on reducing employee surveillance.TikTok policy update confirms Chinese…
Open at close after a big week for earnings and monetary policy
European stocks rose on Friday as markets ended a big week for central bank policy decisions and corporate earnings.The pan-European Stoxx 600 index was up 1.1% by mid-morning, with core resources surging 4.5% to lead the gains as nearly…
European Commission publishes guidelines to strengthen the leniency program
November 3, 2022
Click for PDF
Summary
On October 25, 2022, the European Commission (“the Commission”) issued guidance to clarify and modernize its Leniency Notice for companies seeking…
EU set to adopt mandatory recycled content targets in new packaging law – EURACTIV.com
The European Commission wants to reduce the environmental impact of packaging by requiring producers to use a minimum amount of recycled plastic in new packaging placed on the market.
According to industry group Plastics…
Businessman sees ‘end of an era’ after 30 years in China
German Chancellor Olaf Scholz is due to meet Chinese President Xi Jinping on Friday. Scholz is leading a delegation of business leaders as the first EU leader to visit China since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic. The visit comes less…
The Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra paid $30,000 to take 2 Pa. lawmakers to Europe
PA projector is an independent, nonpartisan newsroom powered by The Philadelphia Inquirer in partnership with PennLive/The Patriot-News, TribLIVE/Pittsburgh Tribune-Review and WITF Public Media. Sign up for our free…
Europe must make this winter the last winter for Russian weapon energy exports
Ukrainians are currently preparing for what will likely be the toughest winter in the country's modern history. As Russia loses on the battlefield, the Kremlin has resorted to all-out war tactics and is trying to destroy Ukraine's civilian…
Aiways works with partners in Europe to ensure end-of-life vehicles and batteries are taken back and…
Always working with partners in Europe to ensure end-of-life vehicles and batteries are taken back and recycled in accordance with the law.
Aiways, the Shanghai start-up, focuses primarily on sustainability. It goes…
Inflation hits new high in Europe, slowing economy
FRANKFURT, Germany — Inflation hit a new high in the 19 countries that use the euro, fueled by runaway natural gas and electricity prices due to Russia's war in Ukraine. Economic growth has also slowed ahead of what economists fear is a…
Northern Ireland’s power-sharing system is ‘not fit for purpose’, says Irish PM
The political stalemate in Northern Ireland, which led to London announcing it would call new elections there, shows that the region's governance system is "not fit for purpose" and should be reformed, according to the Irish Prime…
Kosovo should give Serbs more time to change license plates, EU says
BRUSSELS, Oct 29 (Reuters) - The European Union on Saturday urged Kosovo to allow a longer transition period to phase out old Serbian license plates still used by the country's ethnic Serb minority.Kosovo said on Friday it would delay a…
RLI: Bulgaria at the bottom of Europe in terms of the rule of law – Novinite.com
Bulgaria improved his results on the rule of rightmoving up two positions to 60th from last year's 62nd place among 140 countries, under the rule of Right Index (RLI) of the world Justice Project (WJP) for 2022. Bulgaria country has 55…
McDonald’s executives expect a recession
McDonald's executives expect a recession in the United States, but it will be worse in Europe. / Photo by Jonathan Maze.McDonald's executives expect a recession in the United States and Europe, they told investors Thursday, although they…
European markets open at close, results, data and news
Credit Suisse shares the tankCredit Suisse shares are down more than 14% in European morning trade. Here's how they've fared over the past five days:Credit Suisse shares down 14% after huge loss and corporate overhaulSwiss credit shares…
European Commission proposes tougher pollution restrictions
BRUSSELS (AP) — The executive arm of the European Union on Wednesday sought to tighten pollution restrictions to ensure harmful pollutants are phased out by 2050 to potentially save the lives of hundreds of thousands of…
Spanish clubs to STRIKE against new law backing European Super League –
La Liga Strike: La Liga LIVE - La Liga clubs are adamant about their stance on blocking the European Super League in…
La Liga strike: La Liga LIVE - La Liga clubs are adamant about their stance on blocking the European Super…
Crypto Exchange Coinbase Obtains License to Operate in European Union’s Fifth-Economy
After receiving permission to do business in the Netherlands, which has the fifth largest economy in the European Union, the cryptocurrency exchange Coinbase will start providing its services there.
According to reports, they are now the…
Lastminute.com executives face extended detention as investigation continues
ZURICH, Oct 24 (Reuters) - The chief executive and managing director of Lastminute.com, facing a criminal investigation into the possible abuse of state aid for businesses hit by pandemic shutdowns, has seen his period in custody extended…
ECB eyes giant rate hike again to ‘tame the inflationary beast’ – EURACTIV.com
The European Central Bank is expected to put aside recession worries and make another massive interest rate hike this week to calm inflation, as Russia's war on Ukraine drives up prices for energy.
Inflation in the…
EU warns Germany against buying Chinese port
by Markus Wacket (Reuters) The European Commission warned the German government last spring not to approve an investment by Chinese company Cosco in the port of Hamburg, the German daily Handelsblatt reported on Friday, citing sources.…
Faster ferry journeys; EC approves 12 million euro contract
Photo: Miguela XuerebTista' taqra bil-
Malta.Newsbook.com.mt is informed that the European Commission has approved a two-year contract worth €12 million which will help the operators of the fast ferry between Malta and Gozo to maintain…
European Union chiefs congratulate Meloni on becoming Italian Prime Minister
European Commission chief Ursula von der Leyen on Saturday congratulated far-right leader Giorgia Meloni on her appointment as Italy's prime minister and said she looked forward to "constructive cooperation" with her…
Accelerate career growth with Executive MBA degrees designed specifically for professionals
SharjahWATER, October 22, 2022 /PRNewswire/ -- Britts Imperial University College is one of the leading university colleges in the Middle East offering accredited MBA programs for professionals and students around the world. For busy…
3 Seas Initiative: America’s Opportunity in Europe to Advance National Interests
A statement outlining US support for the Three Seas Initiative brought together a bipartisan group of senators, including Republicans Rob Portman of Ohio and Chuck Grassley of Iowa and Democrats Chris Coons of Delaware, Chris Murphy of…
EU leaders will continue to study gas price caps
BRUSSELS, Oct 20 (Reuters) - European Union leaders ended another debate over the bloc's response to the energy crisis without agreement on whether to cap gas prices, deciding in the early hours of Friday morning to continue to examine…
Page not found | The National Law Review
Legal disclaimer
You are responsible for reading, understanding and agreeing to the National Law Review (NLR) and National Law Forum LLC Terms of Use and Privacy Policy before using the National Law Website. Law Review. The National…
New mental health strategy must involve everyone, EU Commissioner – EURACTIV.com
A mental health strategy, first announced by European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, is on the agenda for next year, said Commission Vice-President Maroš Šefčovič, during a parliamentary plenary debate Tuesday…
US stocks extend rally, Treasury yields fall after strong earnings and economic data
NEW YORK, Oct 18 (Reuters) - Wall Street stocks closed higher and Treasury yields fell on Tuesday as upbeat earnings and better-than-expected factory data fueled a risky rally.Building on Monday's broad gains, the S&P 500 led major US…
The European Commission calls for an increased role in the protection of critical infrastructures
The European Commission on Tuesday proposed giving itself a greater supporting and coordinating role to improve the bloc's preparedness and response to threats to its critical infrastructure.In new recommendations unveiled in Brussels, the…
Definition of ‘recyclability’ takes center stage in EU packaging bill – EURACTIV.com
Defining what is considered "recyclable" has become a point of contention in the EU's overhaul of its packaging waste legislation, with recyclers pushing for lofty targets and producers fearing that products will reach the…
EU imposes human rights sanctions on Iran and warns against Ukraine
Oct 17 (Reuters) - The European Union prepared to impose sanctions on Iran on Monday over a human rights crackdown and several ministers warned of separate new sanctions if Tehran's involvement in Russia's war against Ukraine was proven.EU…
EU leaders set to explore gas price cap options
BRUSSELS, Oct 16 (Reuters) - European Union leaders meeting at the end of this week will explore a series of options for capping gas prices, on which they have been divided for weeks, according to a new draft conclusions for October 20.…
World Economic Outlook, October 2022: Countering the Cost of Living Crisis
Global Perspectives and Policies
The slowdown in global economic activity is widespread and sharper than…
European Commission recognizes COVID-19 certificates issued by Brazil
Even though almost all countries in the European Union have removed coronavirus restrictions, including travel restrictions, the European Commission continues to update the list of coronavirus vaccination certificates issued abroad, which…
EU forces Google and Apple to adopt common USB-C charger, setting global standard
Harnessing its digital strength, the European Union this month forced a major shift for the global tech industry, after giving up hope that companies would choose to change on their own.
In early October, the European Parliament in…
Nigerian bishop calls for help from European Parliament as terror attacks continue
Nigerian authorities have taken a stance of little to no intervention, according to the Bishop.
“At least three Catholic priests have been kidnapped in Nigeria since…
BIMCO requests recognition of non-European shipbreaking yards
BIMCO cites a growing need to recycle large ocean-going vessels (file photo)…
Composite materials for a circular model
There 'Creating a sustainable and competitive economy for the European composites industry' Plan was presented to European SDG Summit. The document, prepared by Leonardo and CSR Europe with the support of Bax & Company, deepens the…
The European Commission launches an online “meeting point” for the robotics community
The European Commission has launched a "meeting point" for the online robotics community.
The EC says its European hub helps explore "the non-technical aspects of robotics that impact society and our lives".
Robospot: The Responsible…
EU biofuel legislation threatens key ingredient for bread and beer – EURACTIV.com
Classifying molasses as a renewable, carbon-free feedstock for biofuels will severely hamper the production of yeast, a key element in the preparation of bread, beer and wine, European yeast producers have warned.
EU yeast…
The European Union joins forces with the WHO to boost vaccination coverage against COVID-19 in…
Jafarasa Sadat, provincial expanded immunization program manager, administers the last injection of the day to Jauado Alifa, a community leader in Malica, a camp for displaced people in Mozambique. ©WHOA €16 million grant to WHO from the…
Axelera AI Appoints Silicon Valley Veteran Jonathan Ballon As Independent Non-Executive Director
EINDHOVEN, Netherlands--(BUSINESS WIRE)--European AI startup Axelera AI named tech veteran Jonathan Ballon to its non-executive board. Ballon joins the only Dutch start-up designing the world's most powerful and advanced solutions…
Next winter will be worse than 2022 for Europe: IMF
The coming winter in Europe will certainly be difficult, but the one that follows will make it pale in comparison.
Europe's energy crisis will plunge the continent into a cold winter
Europe is facing a very difficult winter this year;…
News: NATO Deputy Secretary General stresses importance of “strategic solidarity”…
Speaking at a European Union budget conference in Brussels on Monday October 10, 2022, Deputy Secretary General Mircea Geoană called for "strategic solidarity" between Europe and North America as the best response to a more…
Austria launches legal action against EU ‘greenwashing’ of nuclear and gas
Austria has lodged a complaint against the inclusion of nuclear energy and natural gas on the European Union's list of "green" investments.“What I oppose with all my might is the attempt to green nuclear energy and gas through the back door…
Dapper Labs hits Russian accounts with restrictions, citing EU sanctions
Dapper Labs blocks Russian accounts from using its payment services, the company announced this week.The decision was taken following sanctions imposed by the European Union on Thursday, targeting Russia and Russian nationals. Dapper,…
Ukraine’s economy shrank by 30% in the first three quarters of 2022
Oct 8 (Reuters) - Ukraine's economy shrank around 30% in the first three quarters of 2022 compared to the same period in 2021, largely due to the Russian invasion, the ministry said on Saturday economy.Bad weather in September which slowed…
The European Commission wants to end the secret system protecting fossil fuel reserves | Fossil…
The use of secret corporate panels to protect multi-billion pound fossil fuel investments in Europe could end after a decision by the European Commission.One-off payments such as a recent £210million award to British oil company Rockhopper…
The United States will also benefit from Ukraine’s European integration
The ongoing Russian invasion of Ukraine is already widely recognized as a watershed moment in modern European history. Clearly, the pre-war European security…
EU leaders reaffirm support for Ukraine, squabble over gas price cap
European leaders remain divided on gas price capThe European Commission will make proposals for the EU summitPoland slams Germany for high compensation spendingLeaders pledge continued financial and military aid to UkraineScholz says…
Port of Hambantota – myths and facts
Ro-Ro operations at Hambantota Port (file image)…
A crisis is coming to Europe. The only question is, what type?
European governments face a choice as to what type of crisis to have: an energy crisis or a budget crisis. The global economy could be at stake.Estimates of the magnitude of the energy price shock vary, but a plausible estimate is between…
EU’s next ‘digital product passport’ will include packaging, says official –…
Although packaging as such is not regulated as a separate product category under the EU's proposed eco-design rules for everyday consumer goods, it will be included in the overall assessment of their environmental…
Ugandan minister denounces European Union criticism of mega oil project
By AFP
Uganda's energy minister on Tuesday criticized the European Parliament for seeking to delay a massive and controversial oil project in East Africa over human rights abuses and environmental concerns.France's TotalEnergies…
Faurecia obtains 213 million euros from the EU to develop a hydrogen project in France
Oct 3 (Reuters) - France's Faurecia (EPED.PA) said its hydrogen technology project had received public support of 213 million euros ($208.72 million) from the European Commission in the framework of the Hydrogen IPCEI program.The company…
The rise of isolationism and populism in Europe has parallels with the 1930s. An energy crisis could…
With high inflation, soaring energy prices and slowing economic growth, many economists have drawn comparisons between today's European economy and that of the oil crisis of the 1970s.
But while concerns of 1970s-style stagflation loom…
EU chief: New Greece-Bulgaria gas pipeline ‘means freedom’
Sofia, Bulgaria -- The President of the European Union Executive visited Bulgaria on Saturday for the opening of a gas link between the country and Greece, underlining the EU's determination to no longer depend on Russian imports of energy.…
European Commission Executive Vice-President sees little risk to Irish economy in UK unrest –…
There is very little risk of the UK's financial turmoil spreading to Ireland due to the state's stable economic profile, European Commission Executive Vice-President Margrethe Vestager said in Dublin.Britain's pound fell to a record low…
EU countries to back windfall energy levies and lock horns on gas price cap
BRUSSELS, Sept 30 (Reuters) - European Union countries meet on Friday to approve emergency levies on windfall profits from energy companies and launch talks on their next move to tackle Europe's energy crisis - possibly a gas price…
Danes crippled by inflexible regulations
Strict regulations prevent frustrated Danish universities from accessing the more innovative parts of European University Alliances, but looming elections mean red tape is unlikely to be cut any time soon.
Seven Danish universities are part…
Russia’s nuclear trade with Europe continues despite war in Ukraine – The Denver Post
By Sylvie Corbet
PARIS (AP) — While the European Union has agreed to reduce its use of Russian oil and gas, its member countries continue to import and export nuclear fuel that is not subject to EU sanctions. – much to the chagrin of the…
Biden executive order on data transfers to offer temporary relief to advertisers
When it comes to data-driven surveillance, the writing is already on the wall. The Biden administration is set to sign an executive order on transatlantic data transfers next week, Politico reported on Tuesday. The move could make it easier…
Fundamentally transforming the European economy | theTrumpet.com
"Iinflation” has been dominating global news for months now. Most major economies suffer from high inflation rates. The United States, Mexico, Brazil, the United Kingdom and the Eurozone all have rates above 8%. And inflation is blamed…
Live Updates: Russia’s War in Ukraine
A dispute over payments between Russian gas company Gazprom and Ukrainian gas pipeline operator Naftogaz has escalated, potentially endangering one of the few gas pipelines linking Russia to Europe still in operation.The dispute concerns…
EU debates whether to welcome those fleeing Russia: NPR
The European Union is divided over whether to give refuge to fleeing Russians after President Vladimir Putin announced last week that men with military experience would be called up to fight in Ukraine.
JUANA…
The International Executive Search Federation adds a new member firm in Austria
September 27, 2022 – The International Executive Search Federation (IESF) has expanded to Austria with the addition of YBM Partners as the newest member firm. "Our expansion with Austria as a traditional gateway to Eastern…
Why Switzerland is the best country in the world | Top countries
When it comes to Switzerland, it's not all chocolate and cheese.The country in the heart of Europe is also home to the world's largest public food and nutrition company - Nestlé - and dozens of pharmaceutical companies, including global…
EU and US question Serbia’s EU commitment after Russia deal
Belgrade, Serbia -- The European Union and the United States on Monday questioned Serbia's declared commitment to join the bloc of 27 European nations after Belgrade signed an agreement with Moscow promising long-term "consultations" on…
Ads with unregulated climate claims are a barrier to real emissions cuts – NGO lawyer
What elements of the proposed update to the EU's Unfair Consumer Practices Directive are likely to be most helpful to activists suing companies over false climate claims?
The committee has proposed a veritable series of anti-greenwashing…
Eyes on Belgium as some EU states push for ban on Russian diamonds
Diamonds are pictured during an official presentation by diamond producer Alrosa in Moscow, Russia February 13, 2019. REUTERS/Maxim Shemetov/File PhotoJoin now for FREE unlimited access to Reuters.comRegisterBRUSSELS, Sept 25 (Reuters) -…
Has inflation in the euro zone increased further?
Has inflation in the euro zone increased further?Can inflation maintain its record pace in the euro zone even as the economy already appears to be contracting and economists are widely predicting a recession this winter?The final…
West pushes to deepen sanctions on Russia after Putin escalates threats against Ukraine
WASHINGTON (AP) — How U.S. leaders and their allies intend to respond if President Vladimir Putin seeks a way out of a bad situation on Ukraine's battlefields and follows through on renewed threats to annex a territory…
The European Union wants laws against human rights in Pakistan
Islamabad, September 24: Members of the European Parliament (MEPs), who paid a three-day visit to Pakistan, called for timely reforms and legislative changes on human rights issues, including enforced disappearances…
Latest Dutch Vape Flavor Consultation Ends September 28th
Consumers and vaping advocates have less than a week to take part in the Dutch government's brief public consultation on a vaping product flavor ban that could put current manufacturers out of business next year. The deadline for comments…
Charles Michel in favor of opening the EU to fleeing Russians – POLITICO
Press play to listen to this article
NEW YORK – Europe should allow the entry of Russian citizens seeking to flee the country, European Council President Charles Michel said as he castigated…
Live news: Covid infections rebound in England and Wales
Scotland faces a dilemma following the UK Chancellor's mini-budget as business leaders urge the devolved administration to match tax cuts to avoid further divergence with England which could risk economic underperformance. Leftist critics…